1. Forum
  2. FidoNet
  3. MYSTIC

  • Routing issue

    From Flavio Bessa@4:801/188 to All on Wed Oct 22 12:47:46 2025
    Hello folks,

    I am using Mystic as a Hub for region 80.

    My routing table is as per below:

    Netmail Route (Top-Down Priority)

    Route 1:* 2:* 3:* 4:* !4:801/* to 4:902/26
    Route 3:770/1 to 3:770/1
    Route 4:801/197 to 4:801/197
    Route 4:801/200 to 4:801/200
    Route 4:801/201 to 4:801/201
    Route 4:801/161 to 4:801/161
    Route 4:801/189 to 4:801/189
    Route 4:801/188 to 4:801/188
    Route 4:801/194 to 4:801/194
    Route 4:801/10 to 4:801/10
    Route 4:801/202 to 4:801/202
    Route 4:900/108 to 4:900/108
    Route 4:801/203 to 4:801/203

    So, apart from the locally connected nodes, everything should be routed to 4:902/26, right?

    However, I have received a netmail from Z3 as such:

    + Oct 22 12:30:11 Importing 0d619a84.pkt (4:900/108 to 4:80/1)
    + Oct 22 12:30:11 Route (Paul Hayton@3:770/100 to JAS@4:900/733) via 4:900/108

    And 4:900/108 should not receive any netmail from me.. this netmail towards 4:900/733 should have been routed over 4:902/26... Any specific change I should do on my routing table?

    ... There is an exception to every rule, except this one.

    --- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (macOS/64)
    * Origin: Saturn's Orbit BBS - From Brazil to the World! (4:801/188)
  • From Nick Boel@1:154/10 to Flavio Bessa on Wed Oct 22 18:18:58 2025
    Hey Flavio!

    On Wed, 22 Oct 2025 12:47:46 -0300, you wrote:

    My routing table is as per below:

    Netmail Route (Top-Down Priority)

    Route 1:* 2:* 3:* 4:* !4:801/* to 4:902/26
    Route 3:770/1 to 3:770/1
    Route 4:801/197 to 4:801/197
    Route 4:801/200 to 4:801/200
    Route 4:801/201 to 4:801/201
    Route 4:801/161 to 4:801/161
    Route 4:801/189 to 4:801/189
    Route 4:801/188 to 4:801/188
    Route 4:801/194 to 4:801/194
    Route 4:801/10 to 4:801/10
    Route 4:801/202 to 4:801/202
    Route 4:900/108 to 4:900/108
    Route 4:801/203 to 4:801/203

    So, apart from the locally connected nodes, everything should be routed
    to 4:902/26, right?

    Yes. However, you may not need any of the others, as these are not really "routes", these are direct connections. I think with Mystic you can probably blank out the route line for each of the 'direct' links.

    Or if you'd rather change them to 'route' statements, then for example, route 3:770/1.* to 3:770.1

    However, I have received a netmail from Z3 as such:

    + Oct 22 12:30:11 Importing 0d619a84.pkt (4:900/108 to 4:80/1)
    + Oct 22 12:30:11 Route (Paul Hayton@3:770/100 to JAS@4:900/733) via 4:900/108

    And 4:900/108 should not receive any netmail from me.. this netmail
    towards 4:900/733 should have been routed over 4:902/26... Any specific change I should do on my routing table?

    I'm unsure why it did that, and if all you have is what you wrote above, it definitely shouldn't. but try either of the above and see if it happens again afterwards.

    Regards,
    Nick

    ... Sarcasm: because beating people up is illegal.
    --- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5-b20250409
    * Origin: _thePharcyde telnet://bbs.pharcyde.org (Wisconsin) (1:154/10)
  • From Flavio Bessa@4:801/188 to Nick Boel on Thu Oct 23 12:36:00 2025
    On 22 Oct 2025, Nick Boel said the following...

    Yes. However, you may not need any of the others, as these are not really "routes", these are direct connections. I think with Mystic you can probably blank out the route line for each of the 'direct' links.

    Yeah, I tried that but it did not work out, so I added a route to 4:900/733 towards 4:902/26. Paul's system was resending the netmail frequently, and now from the logs I could see that it was properly routed towards my ZC.

    Anyway I am still puzzled with the previous routing decision :)

    ... Do vegetarians eat animal crackers?

    --- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (macOS/64)
    * Origin: Saturn's Orbit BBS - From Brazil to the World! (4:801/188)